Lord Robertson is disgraceful

Last year, a member of the public claimed on the Sunday Herald’s online messageboard that George Robertson, former NATO secretary, was involved in a cover-up over the Dunblane massacre. This allegation was untrue and defamatory; as soon as Lord Robertson brought the post to the editor’s attention he deleted it and apologised.

Any reasonable person would have left it there – but being unpleasantly litigious, Lord Robertson didn’t. Instead, he sued the newspaper for libel, and won a five-figure sum in damages.

The UK’s libel laws are extremely stupid, for two reasons. The first is that their bias in the plaintiff’s favour means that the main beneficiaries are often crooks, conmen, cheats and liars; the second is that they spread liability far too far (retailers and distributors can be held liable for libels printed in publications that they sell).

Lord Robertson clearly doesn’t fall into any of the former categories, but it’s equally clear that his case falls into the latter. The Herald took all reasonable steps to remove the libel once it was printed, and he would have suffered no damage to his reputation had he accepted the newspaper’s apology.

While I can see that enough money to buy a house (in Scotland at least) for no work would be a pleasant thing to receive, and that Lord Robertson’s actions are in no way unlawful, his actions would appear mercenary and unnecessary in anyone. Since we hold public servants to higher standards than regular citizens, this makes matters significantly worse.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by John B. Bookmark the permalink.

3 thoughts on “Lord Robertson is disgraceful

  1. Dunblane Whitewash is dedicated to the victims, and families and friends of the victims, of the Dunblane massacre, to the victims of the high profile paedophile ring who preyed on vulnerable school children at Queen Victoria School in Dunblane, and finally to the people of Scotland who were subjected to a patronising "show forum", which became known as the Cullen Inquiry Whitewash

  2. How can the public turn a blind eye to establishment perverts who think it’s a perk of the state to sexually and physically abuse God’s children!

Comments are closed.