Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/johnband/sbbs.johnband.org/index.php:1) in /home/johnband/sbbs.johnband.org/wp-includes/feed-rss2-comments.php on line 8
Comments on: Racehorse results improve http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/ As fair-minded and non-partisan as Torquemada. Wed, 07 Mar 2012 07:16:20 +0000 hourly 1 By: Michael http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-8000 Sun, 21 Aug 2005 08:51:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-8000 If you’ve got course work you’ve got to work hard all the time, whereas if it’s an exam you can get by more with cramming nearer the time and with good exam technique.

I suppose it depends on the course you’re doing, but that doesn’t tally with my experience. For starters, we weren’t assessed constantly – the two annual flashpoints were January and May, when we had our coursework deadlines and a handful of exams.

And I’d also argue that it’s far easier to prepare for regular assessments like these than it is to cram the whole of two or three years’ study into a handful of exams spread over a fortnight or so – not least because you can keep a running score of how you’re doing throughout the course, so you don’t have to deal with the hideous uncertainty that you may have blown it through feeling below par right at the end.

]]>
By: Old Peculier http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7999 Sun, 21 Aug 2005 07:47:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7999 People often go on about exams being easier now because there’s more course work. Am I the only person in the world who disagrees? If you’ve got course work you’ve got to work hard all the time, whereas if it’s an exam you can get by more with cramming nearer the time and with good exam technique.

I don’t mean that you can doss around till the last minute – you’ve got to work reasonably steadily – but it’s less stressful than being assessed all the time, surely?

Just a thought. Anyway, it’s a while since I took any exams so maybe it’s rose-coloured specs.

]]>
By: dsquared http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7995 Sat, 20 Aug 2005 10:28:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7995 For all that people bang on about "grade inflation", Matthew Turner’s done the work on the figures and it seems to imply that over the period 1992-2005 it’s been about 2% per year. Lots of countries would love to have a currency that kept its value as well as the A-level.

]]>
By: Michael http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7994 Sat, 20 Aug 2005 07:41:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7994 The other effect of this is a rise in ‘stress’, invariably the media portrays complaints of stress among students as whinging, and in part it may be, however continued assessment and the creation of AS levels which contribute half of the marks of the whole A level, mean that it is no longer possible for a pupil to doss their way through the lower sixth and find a good set of revision notes and do well in their final exams, this constant pressure to perform is the main cause of this stress.

On the other hand, depending on how you approach things, this can actually help reduce stress. My degree was a modular one, and once I’d worked out that the final grade was based on a simple average of the sixteen courses I took across the second and third years (i.e. with no weighting towards particular subjects), my strategy was to work flat out in year two to get a mark much higher than the threshold for a First, and then relax a bit in year three.

Ironically, I ended up scoring better marks in year three, probably because of the relative lack of stress – I suspect I was more inclined to take risks than I might have been if the marks were critically important. The final exam was particularly entertaining: by that stage I was so far ahead of my target that merely turning up and signing my name at the top of the paper would have guaranteed me a 2.1, and I only needed 19% to get a First.

But a strategy like this needs a fair bit of forward planning, ideally right at the start of the course, and I can’t imagine too many 13-year-olds thinking that far ahead.

]]>
By: Ed http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7955 Thu, 18 Aug 2005 19:11:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7955 I don’t know when anyone else on this board took their exams, however, i would wager i took them more recently than anyone else. Every year the papers make a big deal about how standards are slipping and the current exams aren’t as hard as those in the past, however there appear to be a number of trends which have resulted in higher pass rates and a perceived drop in difficulty.

1)
Piecemealisation (if that’s a word), the exams today are broken down into far simpler and smaller chunks than at any point in the past. Whereas a maths exam from 20 years ago would have been 3 hours long, and featured long, verbose questions with multiple interdependent calculations. Today, the candidates face 3, 1 hour exams, each with shorter and more succinct questions, thus a perceived lack of complexity.

2)
The topics covered have changed to reflect changes in ideology and understanding, for example, my father, when looking at some of the work I did as part of my GCSE’s and AS levels swears that many of the topics I covered, he did not cover until degree or the final year of A level. However, other areas such as Logarithms were covered earlier in the past due to the lack of electronic calculators.

3)
The growth of evaluation based study rather than simple rote learning and regurgitation of facts. Increasingly exams are designed less to calculate the pupil’s retention of factual knowledge, and instead judge their ability to evaluate sources and argue an opinion. Thus when the media sets modern pupils old tests, which prize the memorization of dates over the development of argument and critical thinking there are inevitably allegations of ‘dumbing down’ when in fact the exams are testing a completely different and arguably more useful set of skills. Indeed, in the markscheme for A level Government and Politics, less than half the marks for each question are allocated based on the correct factual knowledge, the rest being based on the content of the argument, and the way in which the information was deployed. This of course means that exam technique and following a rubric inevitably take on a greater significance, allowing pupils to be coached that much more easily, learning painting by numbers arguments in which they join the dots on the day, thus undermining the changes made to the exams to favour independent thinking.

4)
The increased importance of continued assessment. In the past, almost all if not all of the candidates marks were allocated based on the results of the final examinations. Today an increasing percentage is based on performance in Coursework, this ranges from 20% in History to 60% or more in subjects like Media Studies. In theory this allows students who perform poorly under the pressure of exams to acheive, however the entire system is wide open to cheating, usually involving teachers who repeatedly mark and return supposedly ‘independent’ work for correction. The temptation to cheat is inevitably higher among lower acheiving schools, and penalises honest schools.
The other effect of this is a rise in ‘stress’, invariably the media portrays complaints of stress among students as whinging, and in part it may be, however continued assessment and the creation of AS levels which contribute half of the marks of the whole A level, mean that it is no longer possible for a pupil to doss their way through the lower sixth and find a good set of revision notes and do well in their final exams, this constant pressure to perform is the main cause of this stress. The modern child will face four years of constant coursework and exam pressure from age 14 onwards, then potentially followed by another three or four years of higher education.

]]>
By: dearieme http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7948 Thu, 18 Aug 2005 13:27:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7948 What a lot of bollocks. In so far as exams and A-levels matter, they ought to be a real test for the youngsters taking them. Having really bright kids taking papers where they score 97% or 98% by use of formulaic, mechanical answering is an empty ritual which can only teach them to despise the whole idea of education. Give the poor sods something to get their teeth into, and, at the same time, do let them know that exams are not the be-all and end-all. Nor, indeed, is academic prowess. But holding bogus exams and then attaching huge significance to the outcome is a cruel, wasteful and destructive nonsense for almost everyone concerned. Stop it.

]]>
By: Ed http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7944 Thu, 18 Aug 2005 12:10:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7944 I have never been swayed by the idea that everyone else’s mediocrity should encourage people not to try as hard. It’s probably true that the actual percentage of the population who go on to further and higher education will remain static, what we should change is the social background of the people who do so, not by punishing the middle class, but by enabling the others to access good quality education and encouraging them to acheive.

]]>
By: chris http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7932 Thu, 18 Aug 2005 09:01:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7932 "Apparently the Guardian’s website is particularly well read in the USA". Mixed blessing. On the one hand it might teach them to spell; on the other, it’s the Graun, so it probably won’t.

]]>
By: Benjamin http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7928 Thu, 18 Aug 2005 07:35:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7928 Apparently the Guardian’s website is particularly well read in the USA.

]]>
By: Matthew http://sbbs.johnband.org/2005/08/racehorse-results-improve/#comment-7927 Thu, 18 Aug 2005 07:30:00 +0000 http://sbbs.johnband.org/?p=1343#comment-7927 Good point Michael. That’s not forgetting its power and influence, which if you read a lot of the Decent Left or Right is now up to the point where it effectively runs the world.

]]>